Wix, Squarespace or a Custom Website? An Honest Comparison

By the CL42ITY team4 min read
In this article

We build custom websites, but we'll be honest: a website builder like Wix or Squarespace is sometimes the right choice. This guide compares the options on cost, speed, SEO and control, so you can decide what fits your business now, with examples of businesses we've moved off builders and one we helped to stay on one.

Website builders: Wix, Squarespace and similar

Builders let you drag and drop a website together from a template, with hosting included in a monthly plan.

  • Good for: new businesses testing an idea, very simple sites, people who enjoy doing it themselves.
  • Typical cost: a monthly plan, plus your time.
  • Watch out for: slower loading on phones, limited control over SEO details, and moving away later can be awkward because you can't take the design with you.

Custom websites

A custom website is designed for your business and built so that every page, heading and image is under control.

  • Good for: established businesses where enquiries matter, competitive local markets, businesses that want to rank for several services and towns.
  • Typical cost: a one-off design and build fee, then a monthly hosting plan. Ours start at £500 for a one-page site and £1,200 for up to five pages, with hosting from £50 a month including small changes.
  • Watch out for: who owns the domain and the content, how changes get made, and what happens if you want to leave.

The four questions that decide it

How important is Google to your business?

If most new customers find you through search, the extra control of a custom site usually pays for itself. If work comes mainly from referrals and you just need a credible page to send people to, a builder may be enough.

How fast does it need to be?

Builders add their own code to every page. A well-made custom site can load much faster, which helps with both Google and impatient visitors on phones. We explain the difference in how we took our own site from 61 to 98.

Who will update it?

If you want to change text and photos weekly yourself, make sure whatever you choose makes that easy. If you'd rather someone else handles it, a custom site with a care plan is simpler: you send the change, it's done.

Will you outgrow it?

Online booking, a shop, multiple locations and connections to other software are where builders start to struggle. Most offer them, but you end up working around the template rather than building what your customers need.

Three real examples

Our own website

CL42ITY's website started on Squarespace. As we added more services, towns and guides, we needed more control over speed and over how each page is structured for Google and AI search. We moved to a custom build, and it now scores in the high 90s for mobile speed on PageSpeed Insights.

Adept Sports Therapy

Adept Sports Therapy was also on Squarespace. The clinic needed its website and online booking to work together smoothly, so we rebuilt it as a custom, booking-ready site and moved it across without touching its email.

TrustForce

Not everyone needs to move. TrustForce runs on Squarespace and that suits how they work, so we designed a calm, trustworthy site within it and built a custom testimonials section where the templates fell short. A builder plus a bit of custom work can be the right middle ground.

Comparing the total cost

Compare the cost over two or three years, not the first month. A builder plan is cheap at the start, but add premium templates, paid apps for booking or forms, and the hours you spend editing, and the gap narrows. A custom site costs more up front, then the monthly hosting covers looking after it. The fair comparison is what each option costs per enquiry it brings in.

For an exact figure for a custom site, use our website cost calculator. Moving an existing site with its pages and rankings intact is £300 on top of the build.

Moving from a builder later

Plenty of businesses start on Squarespace or Wix and move when they grow. It's very doable without losing your Google rankings or email, as long as it's planned: every old address redirected to its new page, titles and descriptions carried over, email records left alone and Search Console checked afterwards. We wrote up how to move off Squarespace safely.

What to check before you commit, either way

  • The domain is registered in your name, not your designer's or the builder's.
  • You can export your pages, text and images if you leave.
  • Your email is set up separately from the website, so moving one never breaks the other.
  • Google Search Console and analytics are connected and you have access.
  • You know who makes changes, how quickly, and what it costs.
  • The site loads quickly on a phone: test it with Google's PageSpeed Insights.

Questions we're often asked

Will moving off Wix or Squarespace hurt my Google rankings?

Not if it's planned. The key is redirecting every old page address to its new home and keeping the content that ranks. Rankings can wobble for a week or two, then usually settle or improve if the new site is faster and better structured.

Can I keep using my builder and just improve it?

Often, yes. Better page titles, a page per service, real photos and a tidy Google Business Profile all help on any platform. Moving only makes sense when the platform itself is holding you back.

Our view

Start with what your business needs in the next two years, not what's cheapest this month. If you'd like a straight recommendation for your situation, even if it's 'stay where you are', book a free call or see our web design service.

The CL42ITY teamWebsite design, branding, photography, video, hosting and SEO agency based in Leicester, working with businesses across the East Midlands.

Need a hand with this?Website designFast, mobile first websites with clear journeys and SEO built in from day one.

Got a question about your own business?

Rather talk? Email info@cl42ity.co.uk or WhatsApp us. We reply within one working day.

Got a project in mind?WhatsApp usEmail us